Team:Brown/Human Practices/Synbio survey

From 2010.igem.org

(Difference between revisions)
 
(33 intermediate revisions not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{:Team:Brown/templates/header}}
{{:Team:Brown/templates/header}}
 +
=Synthetic Biology Campus Survey=
 +
[[Image:Tagcloud.jpg|frame|900px|center|Weighted tag cloud of phrases that people associated with synthetic biology (from a list)]]
-
==Survey==
 
-
This will be the page for the survey results and analysis
 
-
[[Image:Brown_chart_007.png]]
+
 
 +
We were interested in how the rest of the community at Brown University perceived Synthetic Biology. We created a survey this fall and digitally distributed it across campus. The results, taken from 457 respondents, are as follows:
===Demographic Questions===
===Demographic Questions===
Line 11: Line 12:
[[Image:Brown_chart_014.png]]
[[Image:Brown_chart_014.png]]
 +
 +
The majority of our respondents were undergraduates, although a significant number of faculty and/or graduate students offered their opinions as well.
'''How would you describe your gender?'''
'''How would you describe your gender?'''
[[Image:Brown_chart_010.png]]
[[Image:Brown_chart_010.png]]
 +
 +
Respondents were about 2/3 female, 1/3 male.
'''What is the most recent level of education you've completed?'''
'''What is the most recent level of education you've completed?'''
[[Image:Brown_chart_018.png]]
[[Image:Brown_chart_018.png]]
 +
 +
Again, most of the respondents were university students. We suspect that many of those who answered 'High School' also fell into the 'Some College' category, so for the purpose of analyses these two will be grouped.
'''What is the highest level of education you plan to attain?'''
'''What is the highest level of education you plan to attain?'''
[[Image:Brown_chart.png]]
[[Image:Brown_chart.png]]
 +
 +
More than 80% of respondents are seeking at least a Master's degree.
'''What is your level of biology education?'''
'''What is your level of biology education?'''
[[Image:Brown_chart_017.png]]
[[Image:Brown_chart_017.png]]
 +
 +
There is a good spread of biology education in our respondents, which lends itself well to analysis. Very few respondents had absolutely no biology education.
'''How would you classify your concentration?'''
'''How would you classify your concentration?'''
Line 44: Line 55:
'''Define what you think Synthetic Biology is (or might be)'''
'''Define what you think Synthetic Biology is (or might be)'''
 +
It appears that "synthetic biology" is a phrase that evokes many different images in people's minds. While some respondents are familiar with the academic field that iGEM celebrates, others associate it solely with the creation of life and new organisms (a la Craig Venter). Yet another common understanding emphasizes the "synthetic" portion, focusing on the incorporation of inorganic material with living organisms.
 +
Some sample responses:
-
===Uses of Synthetic Biology===
+
*"Man's manipulation of nature for a better explantion of the end result, or to obtain a better end result."
-
We told respondents at the beginning of this page of the survey:
+
*"Synthetic biology is the field of creating new innovations using the systems available in nature."
-
Wikipedia defines Synthetic Biology as: "Synthetic biology encompasses a variety of different approaches, methodologies and disciplines, and many different definitions exist. What they all have in common, however, is that they see synthetic biology as the design and construction of new biological functions and systems not found in nature."
+
*"The creation and study of organisms derived through synthetic means."
 +
*"Synthesizing life in a laboratory setting to perform tasks."
 +
*"a way to merge something living with inanimate objects"
 +
===Uses of Synthetic Biology===
'''What words would you use to describe synthetic biology? (from a list)'''
'''What words would you use to describe synthetic biology? (from a list)'''
[[Image:Brown_chart_012.png]]
[[Image:Brown_chart_012.png]]
-
[[Image:Tagcloud.jpg]]
 
'''Pick 2 areas you think would most benefit from synthetic biology'''
'''Pick 2 areas you think would most benefit from synthetic biology'''
[[Image:Brown_chart_005.png]]
[[Image:Brown_chart_005.png]]
-
 
-
'''What's the coolest use of synthetic biology you can think of?'''
 
-
 
Line 68: Line 80:
[[Image:Brown_chart_003.png]]
[[Image:Brown_chart_003.png]]
-
===Human Practices / Ethics===
+
1 - Disagree strongly -> 5 - Agree strongly
 +
 
 +
===Human Practices / Ethics===  
 +
'''(for all: 1 - Disagree strongly -> 5 - Agree strongly)'''
 +
 
'''I am concerned about the deliberate misuse/abuse of genetically modified organisms'''
'''I am concerned about the deliberate misuse/abuse of genetically modified organisms'''
[[Image:Brown_chart_009.png]]
[[Image:Brown_chart_009.png]]
 +
 +
It is interesting that this question created the greatest divide among our subjects. There appears to be two camps of people, who are either worried about misuse of genetically modified organisms or not.
 +
 +
'''I am concerned about the unintended consequences of genetically modified organisms'''
'''I am concerned about the unintended consequences of genetically modified organisms'''
[[Image:Brown_chart_004.png]]
[[Image:Brown_chart_004.png]]
 +
 +
1 - Disagree strongly -> 5 - Agree strongly
'''There should be greater restrictions on genetic modification of plants/animals'''
'''There should be greater restrictions on genetic modification of plants/animals'''
[[Image:Brown_chart_015.png]]
[[Image:Brown_chart_015.png]]
 +
 +
'''Genetically modified organisms can be beneficial to society'''
'''Genetically modified organisms can be beneficial to society'''
[[Image:Brown_chart_011.png]]
[[Image:Brown_chart_011.png]]
 +
 +
'''It is currently easy to genetically modify a plant/animal'''
'''It is currently easy to genetically modify a plant/animal'''
[[Image:Brown_chart_008.png]]
[[Image:Brown_chart_008.png]]
 +
 +
'''Genetic modification is morally/ethically wrong'''
'''Genetic modification is morally/ethically wrong'''
Line 94: Line 122:
[[Image:Brown_chart_016.png]]
[[Image:Brown_chart_016.png]]
-
===Other Thoughts===
+
===Discussion===
 +
'''What's the coolest use of synthetic biology you can think of?'''
 +
 
 +
Energy and human health were two common applications, corroborating our other data that these were the two fields people thought would benefit the most.
 +
 
 +
Sample responses:
 +
*"Maybe developing a solar panel that can create energy as a biological system (in a way a biological system/organism would) instead of using expensive solar crystals and cells."
 +
*"some really efficient biogas making bacteria that don't need a lot of input."
 +
*"Creating living bio-homes with fluorescent bacteria instead of electrical lighting, with the actual home made of a modular living creation that is basically autotrophic."
 +
*"perhaps finding a way to fix atmospheric carbon into a solid state carbon--reducing global warming"
 +
*"Engineering synthetic or genetically engineering bacteria or algae to produce fossil fuel supplements or replacements."
 +
*"Make me an interface where I can watch Youtube videos directly into my brain."
 +
*"Drug delivery mechanisms."
 +
*"Using synthesized viruses or bacteria to fight cancer."
 +
*"Yeast that are able to withstand higher alcohol concentrations and therefore produce higher alcohol content beer."
 +
 
'''Do you have any other opinions or thoughts on synthetic biology that you would like to share with us?'''
'''Do you have any other opinions or thoughts on synthetic biology that you would like to share with us?'''
 +
There was much insight from people spanning all ages and academic disciplines. Some emphasized their enthusiasm for the emerging field of synthetic biology, while others acknowledged legal, philosophical, and scientific implications. Finally, the issue of regulation and commercialization proved to be an interesting topic for many.
 +
Sample responses:
-
==Analysis==
+
*"I think that synthetic biology has great promise in many different fields.  I do believe, however, that regulations need to be put in place sooner rather than later to avoid unintended consequences."
 +
*"It seems like a mistake to be creating organisms before we have a better understanding of micro- and macrobiological interactions; the number of possible interacting groups of organisms increases exponentially with the number of organisms, and I don't think that humanity has enough knowledge to understand the implications of a given change until it has occurred."
 +
*"I think governmental regulation of synthetic organism creation is too strong due to ignorance/paranoia of the public. However, I think it is important to rigorously teach ethics of biosynthesis to everyone who wants to do it, but maybe have ethical policy monitored within scientific circles, and/or get the public involved more."
 +
*"I believe intentions are important but can easily become lost in the for-profit industry.  This is my strongest concern with synthetic biology."
 +
*"I think that synthetic biology perhaps has beneficial uses, but I think it is dangerous (like all science) in its assumption or potential assumptions and in that our legal systems does not have the capacity to keep up with rapid changes in biological science."
 +
*"People haven negative views on synthetic biology because it is breaking the line between manipulating inorganic objects to perform new functions and manipulating organic objects.  This line can be considered dangerous because we are organic objects, and will have fear that this technology may change who or what we are.  I believe that in order for the development of synthetic biology to be successful, the common people needs to be assured that humans as a species will not change fundamentally."

Latest revision as of 16:23, 27 October 2010

Synthetic Biology Campus Survey

Weighted tag cloud of phrases that people associated with synthetic biology (from a list)


We were interested in how the rest of the community at Brown University perceived Synthetic Biology. We created a survey this fall and digitally distributed it across campus. The results, taken from 457 respondents, are as follows:

Demographic Questions

How old are you?

Brown chart 014.png

The majority of our respondents were undergraduates, although a significant number of faculty and/or graduate students offered their opinions as well.

How would you describe your gender?

Brown chart 010.png

Respondents were about 2/3 female, 1/3 male.

What is the most recent level of education you've completed?

Brown chart 018.png

Again, most of the respondents were university students. We suspect that many of those who answered 'High School' also fell into the 'Some College' category, so for the purpose of analyses these two will be grouped.

What is the highest level of education you plan to attain?

Brown chart.png

More than 80% of respondents are seeking at least a Master's degree.

What is your level of biology education?

Brown chart 017.png

There is a good spread of biology education in our respondents, which lends itself well to analysis. Very few respondents had absolutely no biology education.

How would you classify your concentration?

Brown chart 006.png

Familiarity with Synthetic Biology

Have you heard of "Synthetic Biology" before?

Brown chart 013.png

If yes, where?

Brown chart 002.png

Define what you think Synthetic Biology is (or might be)

It appears that "synthetic biology" is a phrase that evokes many different images in people's minds. While some respondents are familiar with the academic field that iGEM celebrates, others associate it solely with the creation of life and new organisms (a la Craig Venter). Yet another common understanding emphasizes the "synthetic" portion, focusing on the incorporation of inorganic material with living organisms.

Some sample responses:

  • "Man's manipulation of nature for a better explantion of the end result, or to obtain a better end result."
  • "Synthetic biology is the field of creating new innovations using the systems available in nature."
  • "The creation and study of organisms derived through synthetic means."
  • "Synthesizing life in a laboratory setting to perform tasks."
  • "a way to merge something living with inanimate objects"

Uses of Synthetic Biology

What words would you use to describe synthetic biology? (from a list)

Brown chart 012.png


Pick 2 areas you think would most benefit from synthetic biology

Brown chart 005.png


Synthetic biology is the future of biology

Brown chart 003.png

1 - Disagree strongly -> 5 - Agree strongly

Human Practices / Ethics

(for all: 1 - Disagree strongly -> 5 - Agree strongly)


I am concerned about the deliberate misuse/abuse of genetically modified organisms

Brown chart 009.png

It is interesting that this question created the greatest divide among our subjects. There appears to be two camps of people, who are either worried about misuse of genetically modified organisms or not.


I am concerned about the unintended consequences of genetically modified organisms

Brown chart 004.png

1 - Disagree strongly -> 5 - Agree strongly

There should be greater restrictions on genetic modification of plants/animals

Brown chart 015.png


Genetically modified organisms can be beneficial to society

Brown chart 011.png


It is currently easy to genetically modify a plant/animal

Brown chart 008.png


Genetic modification is morally/ethically wrong

Brown chart 016.png

Discussion

What's the coolest use of synthetic biology you can think of?

Energy and human health were two common applications, corroborating our other data that these were the two fields people thought would benefit the most.

Sample responses:

  • "Maybe developing a solar panel that can create energy as a biological system (in a way a biological system/organism would) instead of using expensive solar crystals and cells."
  • "some really efficient biogas making bacteria that don't need a lot of input."
  • "Creating living bio-homes with fluorescent bacteria instead of electrical lighting, with the actual home made of a modular living creation that is basically autotrophic."
  • "perhaps finding a way to fix atmospheric carbon into a solid state carbon--reducing global warming"
  • "Engineering synthetic or genetically engineering bacteria or algae to produce fossil fuel supplements or replacements."
  • "Make me an interface where I can watch Youtube videos directly into my brain."
  • "Drug delivery mechanisms."
  • "Using synthesized viruses or bacteria to fight cancer."
  • "Yeast that are able to withstand higher alcohol concentrations and therefore produce higher alcohol content beer."


Do you have any other opinions or thoughts on synthetic biology that you would like to share with us?

There was much insight from people spanning all ages and academic disciplines. Some emphasized their enthusiasm for the emerging field of synthetic biology, while others acknowledged legal, philosophical, and scientific implications. Finally, the issue of regulation and commercialization proved to be an interesting topic for many.

Sample responses:

  • "I think that synthetic biology has great promise in many different fields. I do believe, however, that regulations need to be put in place sooner rather than later to avoid unintended consequences."
  • "It seems like a mistake to be creating organisms before we have a better understanding of micro- and macrobiological interactions; the number of possible interacting groups of organisms increases exponentially with the number of organisms, and I don't think that humanity has enough knowledge to understand the implications of a given change until it has occurred."
  • "I think governmental regulation of synthetic organism creation is too strong due to ignorance/paranoia of the public. However, I think it is important to rigorously teach ethics of biosynthesis to everyone who wants to do it, but maybe have ethical policy monitored within scientific circles, and/or get the public involved more."
  • "I believe intentions are important but can easily become lost in the for-profit industry. This is my strongest concern with synthetic biology."
  • "I think that synthetic biology perhaps has beneficial uses, but I think it is dangerous (like all science) in its assumption or potential assumptions and in that our legal systems does not have the capacity to keep up with rapid changes in biological science."
  • "People haven negative views on synthetic biology because it is breaking the line between manipulating inorganic objects to perform new functions and manipulating organic objects. This line can be considered dangerous because we are organic objects, and will have fear that this technology may change who or what we are. I believe that in order for the development of synthetic biology to be successful, the common people needs to be assured that humans as a species will not change fundamentally."
Retrieved from "http://2010.igem.org/Team:Brown/Human_Practices/Synbio_survey"