Team:TU Delft/Project/sensing/results

From 2010.igem.org

(Difference between revisions)

Latest revision as of 22:50, 27 October 2010

Sensing Results and Conclusions

[http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 BBa_K398326 (pCaiF)] strength

[http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 BBa_K398326 (pCaiF)] is by far the smallest part of our project. This part enable the expression of proteins at low glucose concentrations in order to mimic a diauxic shift for the alkane degradation system: Once the preferred substrate, glucose becomes limiting, the expression of alkane degradation genes under pCaiF control will enable the cells to shift from glucose metabolism to alkane degradation. The whole regulation is performed by a piece of just 51 bp.

The pCaiF regulation mechanism is really simple, [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 BBa_K398326 (pCaiF)] contains a cAMP-crp complex binding domain, cAMP-crp is known as transcriptional regulator. When the glucose concentration in the environment is high, cAMP levels are low because there is a lot of energy source that can be metabolized by the cells. However during starvation periods cAMP levels increase and thus the concentration of the complex cAMP-crp that is known to activate at least 180 genes related to starvation response. Among those pCaiF a protein used during Carnitine anaerobic metabolism.

An organism expressing our proteins using [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 BBa_K398326 (pCaiF)] could not be constructed. Nevertheless, we studied the regulatory Biobrick [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 BBa_K398326] using [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_E0240 BBa_E0240] in order to measure the output given by our part.

LB medium

First we used a rich medium (LB) and we diluted it with M9 medium without glucose (50% v/v) in order to show the differences in protein expression when the carbon source concentration is lower in a rich medium.

Figure 1. GFP and Biomass profiles in LB growth. (A) Normal LB and (B) LB diluted 50% with M9 medium without C-source.

Our findings suggest that there is GFP production when the LB medium is diluted 50%. However the fluorescence signal produced was weak, moreover we didn't see an increase of GFP production during the stationary phase (starvation). This could be due to the fact that LB medium can keep the cAMP levels low for long periods of time.

M9 minimal medium

We then tested the response of pCaiF using minimal M9 medium at glucose concentrations of 10 g/L, 5 g/L and 2 g/L. From this experiment we expected to see a limitation of carbon source leading to a reponse by pCaiF.

Figure 2. GFP and Biomass profiles in M9 medium at different initial glucose concentrations.

In this experiment we clearly saw a significant increase in GFP production when the glucose initial concentration was 2 g/L compared to our result for an initial glucose concentration of 10 g/L; whereas at 5 g/L we found a slight increase in GFP production at the end of our measurements. From these plots we can conclude that our part is sensitive to cAMP levels as we expected. Moreover, we found that our part is active under carbon limitation conditions; which in our case it is detected at the beginning of stationary phase at low initial glucose concentrations, see figure.

Figure 3. GFP profiles in M9 medium at different initial glucose concentrations.

Diauxic shift

In order to see the effect of a second carbon source in the medium, we decided to decrease the initial glucose amount to 1 g/L and we added Potassium Laurate at a final concentration of 5 mM (secondary carbon source). This experiment is very close to the later application as lauric acid is metabolized via beta oxidation. We expect to observe a diauxic shift with high GFP expression during the lag phase of the metabolic switch.

Figure 4. GFP and Biomass profiles in M9 medium with glucose concentration of 1 g/L and Potassium Laurate (5mM) as secondary carbon source.

Our findings in this experiment were really interesting, (1) the GFP signal first increases, indicating a limitation due to glucose depletion and (2) the GFP production decreases again when the catabolism of the second carbon source (lauric acid) starts. There is a clear change in the slope for the GFP profile over time with a max at about 8h.

Does [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 pCaiF] really works under starvation conditions???

We had some doubts about the activity of pCaiF in the stationary phase because we usually observed a leaky production of GFP that followed the biomass profile. Therefore we decided to compare the GFP production during the exponential and stationary phase.

Figure 5.Comparison of the GFP production rates during exponential and stationary phase.

According to our results, there is indeed a difference between both conditions. Which is specially clear when the glucose initial concentration is 2 g/L. For the Laurate enriched medium (diauxic shift) we observed a remaining activity from the glucose limitation period and then a clear reduction during Laurate consumption.

[http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 BBa_K398326 pCaiF] in numbers

In order to convert Fluorescence arbitrary units to something meaningful, we used the parameters suggest in the part registry for [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_E0040 E0040]. We divided the fluorescence random units by 79.429 (conversion factor to nM), then we calculated back the number of moles per well knowing that our reaction volume was 100 uL. If we multiply the total amount of moles per well by the [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avogadro_constant Avogadro's constant], we will get the total amount of GFP molecules produced in each data point. Then we applied a linear regression to each growth phase and we divided by the O.D. at 600nm in order to normalize the result ([http://partsregistry.org/RiPS RiPS]/O.D.).

Condition	Exponential phase [GFP molecules/O.D.]	Stationary phase [GFP molecules/O.D.]
LB	1.2516E+07	-8.6245E+05
0.5LB	1.8101E+07	-2.5945E+05
[glc]=10g/L	6.6456E+06	-6.7109E+06
[glc]=5g/L	8.3673E+06	4.2339E+06
[glc]=2g/L	7.2869E+06	3.9755E+07
Diauxic growth (GLUCOSE PHASE)	7.4517E+06	2.1543E+07
DIAUXIC GROWTH (LAURATE PHASE)	1.1435E+07	6.6428E+06

NOTE: Check at the part registry the definition of [http://partsregistry.org/RiPS RiPS]

Conclusions

The simple pCaiF promoter with crp-cAMP binding site has shown activity under limiting nutrient conditions. Therefore, this promoter can be used to enable catabolic shifts from glucose to new degradation pathways.

From our point of view, this part will be very useful for future teams. Please also check the results obtained for the model developed for this part: pCaiF regulation model

Future Prospects

We would have liked to express our results according to the protocols [http://partsregistry.org/PoPS in the part registry]. Therefore the output of [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_B0032 B0032] and a standard promoter growing on M9 medium has to be measured.

@@ Line 2: / Line 2: @@
 {{Team:TU_Delft/frame_check}}
 <html><center><img src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2010/0/00/TU_Delft_project_navigation.jpg" usemap="#projectnavigation" border="0" /></center><map id="projectnavigation" name="projectnavigation"><area shape="rect" alt="Characterization" title="" coords="309,3,591,45" href="https://2010.igem.org/Team:TU_Delft#page=Project/sensing/characterization" target="" /><area shape="rect" alt="Results" title="" coords="609,3,891,44" href="https://2010.igem.org/Team:TU_Delft#page=Project/sensing/results" target="" /><area shape="rect" alt="Parts" title="" coords="9,3,290,44" href="https://2010.igem.org/Team:TU_Delft#page=Project/sensing/parts" target="" /></map></html>
-==Sensing Results==
-===pCaiF strength===
+==Sensing Results and Conclusions ==
-====[http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 BBa_K398326 pCaiF]====
+[[Image:TU_Delft_pCaiF_RNApol.jpg]]
-[http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 BBa_K398326 (pCaiF)] is by far the smallest part of our project; as we explained before we looked for a promoter that could enable the expression proteins under low glucose concentrations in order to mimic a diauxic shift for the alkane degradation system: once the glucose starts to be limiting factor the expression of alkane degradation genes under pCaiF control will enable (theoreticallly) to the cells shift from glucose metabolism to alkane degradation, everything done by a piece of just 51 bp.
-The pCaiF regulation mechanism is really simple, [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 BBa_K398326 (pCaiF)] contains a cAMP-crp complex binding domain, cAMP-crp is known as transcriptional regulator. When glucose concentrations in the surroundings are high, cAMP levels are low because there is a lot of energy source that can be metabolized by the cells; however during starvation periods cAMP levels increase and thus the concentration of the complex cAMP-crp activating at least 180 genes related to starvation  response.  Among those CaiF a protein used during Carnitine anaerobic metabolism.
+===[http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 BBa_K398326 (pCaiF)] strength===
+[http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 BBa_K398326 (pCaiF)] is by far the smallest part of our project. This part enable the expression of proteins at low glucose concentrations in order to mimic a diauxic shift for the alkane degradation system: Once the preferred substrate, glucose becomes limiting, the expression of alkane degradation genes under pCaiF control will enable the cells to shift from glucose metabolism to alkane degradation. The whole regulation is performed by a piece of just 51 bp.
-=====LB medium=====
+The pCaiF regulation mechanism is really simple, [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 BBa_K398326 (pCaiF)] contains a cAMP-crp complex binding domain, cAMP-crp is known as transcriptional regulator. When the glucose concentration in the environment is high, cAMP levels are low because there is a lot of energy source that can be metabolized by the cells. However during starvation periods cAMP levels increase and thus the concentration of the complex cAMP-crp that is known to activate at least 180 genes related to starvation  response.  Among those pCaiF a protein used during Carnitine anaerobic metabolism.
-Due to time constraints we couldn't make a more elegant circuit or express our proteins using [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 BBa_K398326 (pCaiF)], however we wanted to show that the part does what we expected: Protein production at low glucose concentrations. We attached a GFP generator in order to measure the output of our part. First we used a rich medium (LB) and we diluted it with M9 medium without glucose (50% v/v) in order to show the differences in protein expression when the carbon source concentration is lower in a rich medium.
+An organism expressing our proteins using [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 BBa_K398326 (pCaiF)] could not be constructed. Nevertheless, we studied the regulatory Biobrick  [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 BBa_K398326] using [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_E0240 BBa_E0240] in order to measure the output given by our part.
-[[Image:TU_Delft_pCaiF_LB.jpg|600px|thumb|center| GFP and Biomass profiles in LB growth. (A) Normal LB and (B) LB diluted 50% with M9 medium without C-source.]]
+====LB medium====
+First we used a rich medium (LB) and we diluted it with M9 medium without glucose (50% v/v) in order to show the differences in protein expression when the carbon source concentration is lower in a rich medium.
-Our findings suggest that there is a slight improvement on GFP production when the LB medium is diluted 50%. However the fluorescence produced is a really low signal and we didn't see an increase of GFP production during the stationary phase (starvation). This could be due to the fact that LB medium can keep the cAMP levels low for long periods of time.
+[[Image:TU_Delft_pCaiF_LB.jpg|600px|thumb|center|'''Figure 1.''' GFP and Biomass profiles in LB growth. (A) Normal LB and (B) LB diluted 50% with M9 medium without C-source.]]
-=====M9 minimal medium=====
+Our findings suggest that there is  GFP production when the LB medium is diluted 50%. However the fluorescence signal produced was weak, moreover we didn't see an increase of GFP production during the stationary phase (starvation). This could be due to the fact that LB medium can keep the cAMP levels low for long periods of time.
-We also tested the response of pCaiF using minimal M9 medium at glucose concentrations of 10 g/L, 5 g/L and 2 g/L. From this experiment we expected to see how pCaiF responses when the starvation phase starts earlier during normal ''E. coli'' cultures.
+====M9 minimal medium====
+We then tested the response of pCaiF using minimal M9 medium at glucose concentrations of 10 g/L, 5 g/L and 2 g/L. From this experiment we expected to see a limitation of carbon source leading to a reponse by pCaiF.
+[[Image:TU_Delft_pCaiF_glucose.jpg|600px|thumb|center|'''Figure 2.''' GFP and Biomass profiles in M9 medium at different initial glucose  concentrations.]]
-[[Image:TU_Delft_pCaiF_glucose.jpg|600px|thumb|center| GFP and Biomass profiles in M9 medium at different initial glucose  concentrations.]]
+In this experiment we clearly saw a significant increase in GFP production when the glucose initial concentration was 2 g/L compared to our result for an initial glucose concentration of 10 g/L; whereas at 5 g/L we found a slight increase in GFP production at the end of our measurements. From these plots we can conclude that our part is sensitive to cAMP levels as we expected. Moreover, we found that our part is active under carbon limitation conditions; which in our case it is detected at the beginning of stationary phase at low initial glucose concentrations, see figure.
-In this experiment we clearly saw a significant increase in GFP production when the glucose initial concentration was 2 g/L compared to our result for an initial glucose concentration of 10 g/L; whereas at 5 g/L we found a slight increase in GFP production at the end of our measurements. From these plots we can conclude that our part is sensitive to cAMP levels as we expected. Moreover, we found that our part is active under starvation periods (stationary phase at low glucose concentrations). We overlapped the plots in order to show the differences between the different conditions tested.
+[[Image:TU_Delft_pCaiF_comp.jpg|600px|thumb|center|'''Figure 3.''' GFP profiles in M9 medium at different initial glucose  concentrations.]]
-[[Image:TU_Delft_pCaiF_comp.jpg|600px|thumb|center| GFP profiles in M9 medium at different initial glucose  concentrations.]]
+====Diauxic shift====
+In order to see the effect of a second carbon source in the medium, we decided to decrease the initial glucose amount to 1 g/L and we added Potassium Laurate at a final concentration of 5 mM (secondary carbon source). This experiment is very close to the later application as lauric acid is metabolized via beta oxidation. We expect to observe a diauxic shift with high GFP expression during the lag phase of the metabolic switch.
-=====Diauxic shift=====
+[[Image:TU_Delft_pCaiF_diauxic.jpg|600px|thumb|center|'''Figure 4.''' GFP and Biomass profiles in M9 medium with glucose concentration of 1 g/L and Potassium Laurate (5mM) as secondary carbon source.]]
-In order to see the effect of a second carbon source in the medium, we decided to low down even more the initial glucose amount to 1 g/L and we added Potassium Laurate at a final concentration of 5 mM. With this experiment we expected to see how the GFP profile behaves when cAMP levels drop because of the catabolism of a second carbon source.
-[[Image:TU_Delft_pCaiF_diauxic.jpg|600px|thumb|center| GFP and Biomass profiles in M9 medium with glucose concentration of 1 g/L and Potassium Laurate (5mM) as secondary carbon source.]]
+Our findings in this experiment were really interesting, (1) the GFP signal first increases, indicating a limitation due to glucose depletion and (2) the GFP production decreases again when the catabolism of the second carbon source (lauric acid) starts. There is a clear change in the slope for the GFP profile over time with a max at about 8h.
-Our findings in this experiment were really interesting, because as we expected the GFP production decreases when the catabolism of the secondary carbon source starts. You can check that in the plot because of the change in the slope for the GFP profile.
+====Does [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 pCaiF] really works under starvation conditions???====
+We had some doubts about the activity of pCaiF in the stationary phase because we usually observed a leaky production of GFP that followed the biomass profile. Therefore we decided to compare the GFP production during the exponential and stationary phase.
-===== Does [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 pCaiF] really works under starvation conditions???=====
-We had some doubts about the activity of pCaiF under starvation periods because we saw all the time a leaky production of GFP that followed the biomass profile. We decided to compare the GFP production during exponential phase and stationary phase.
-[[Image:TU_Delft_pCaiF_final2.jpg|600px|thumb|center|Comparison of the GFP production rates during exponential and stationary phase.]]
+[[Image:TU_Delft_pCaiF_final2.jpg|600px|thumb|center|'''Figure 5.'''Comparison of the GFP production rates during exponential and stationary phase.]]
-According to our results, there is indeed a difference between both conditions. Which is specially clear when the glucose initial concentration is 2 g/L. For the Laurate growth phase in the diauxic experiment we saw a remaining activity from the glucose starvation period and during Laurate consumption we saw a reduction in the GFP production as we expected.
+According to our results, there is indeed a difference between both conditions. Which is specially clear when the glucose initial concentration is 2 g/L. For the Laurate enriched medium (diauxic shift) we observed a remaining activity from the glucose limitation period and then a clear reduction during Laurate consumption.
-=====[http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 BBa_K398326 pCaiF] IN NUMBERS=====
+====[http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_K398326 BBa_K398326 pCaiF] in numbers====
-In order to convert Fluorescence arbitrary units to something meaningful, we used the parameters suggest in the part registry for [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_E0040 E0040], we divided the fluorescence random units by 79.429 (conversion factor to nM), then we calculated back the number of moles per well knowing that our reaction volume was 100 uL. If we multiply the total amount of moles per well by the [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avogadro_constant Avogadro's constant], we will get the total amount of GFP molecules produced in each data point. Then we applied a linear regression to each growth phase and we divided by the O.D. at 600nm in order to normaize the result ([http://partsregistry.org/RiPS RiPS]/O.D.).
+In order to convert Fluorescence arbitrary units to something meaningful, we used the parameters suggest in the part registry for [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_E0040 E0040]. We divided the fluorescence random units by 79.429 (conversion factor to nM), then we calculated back the number of moles per well knowing that our reaction volume was 100 uL. If we multiply the total amount of moles per well by the [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avogadro_constant Avogadro's constant], we will get the total amount of GFP molecules produced in each data point. Then we applied a linear regression to each growth phase and we divided by the O.D. at 600nm in order to normalize the result ([http://partsregistry.org/RiPS RiPS]/O.D.).
 <table class="tableizer-table">
-<tr class="tableizer-firstrow"><th>Condition</th><th>Exponential phase [RiPS/O.D.] </th><th>Stationary phase [RiPS/O.D.]</th></tr> <tr><td>&nbsp;</td><td>&nbsp;</td><td>&nbsp;</td></tr> <tr><td>LB</td><td>1.2516E+07</td><td>-8.6245E+05</td></tr> <tr><td>0.5LB</td><td>1.8101E+07</td><td>-2.5945E+05</td></tr> <tr><td>10g/L</td><td>6.6456E+06</td><td>-6.7109E+06</td></tr> <tr><td>5g/L</td><td>8.3673E+06</td><td>4.2339E+06</td></tr> <tr><td>2g/L</td><td>7.2869E+06</td><td>3.9755E+07</td></tr> <tr><td>1g/L (glucose phase)</td><td>7.4517E+06</td><td>2.1543E+07</td></tr> <tr><td>1g/L (Laurate phase)</td><td>1.1435E+07</td><td>6.6428E+06</td></tr></table>
+<tr class="tableizer-firstrow"><th>Condition</th><th>Exponential phase [GFP molecules/O.D.] </th><th>Stationary phase [GFP molecules/O.D.]</th></tr> <tr><td>LB</td><td>1.2516E+07</td><td>-8.6245E+05</td></tr> <tr><td>0.5LB</td><td>1.8101E+07</td><td>-2.5945E+05</td></tr> <tr><td> [glc]=10g/L</td><td>6.6456E+06</td><td>-6.7109E+06</td></tr> <tr><td>[glc]=5g/L</td><td>8.3673E+06</td><td>4.2339E+06</td></tr> <tr><td>[glc]=2g/L</td><td>7.2869E+06</td><td>3.9755E+07</td></tr> <tr><td>Diauxic growth (GLUCOSE PHASE)</TD><TD>7.4517E+06</TD><TD>2.1543E+07</TD></TR> <TR><TD>DIAUXIC GROWTH (LAURATE PHASE)</TD><TD>1.1435E+07</TD><TD>6.6428E+06</TD></TR></TABLE>
-NOTE: Check at the part registry the definition of [http://partsregistry.org/RiPS RiPS]
-Properly, we should express everything in terms of [http://partsregistry.org/PoPS Polymerase Per Second] (PoPS); however we lack of data about the output of B0032 and a standard promoter growing the cells in M9 medium. Thus, the mRNA production by this promoter remains unknown; nevertheless with this results we are reporting the protein production using a Promoter-RBS combination that could become standard for other teams that would decide to express their proteins under glucose starvation.
-We developed a simple model, in order to explain in silico what happens with the cAMP levels. If you want to know more about this check our [ in silico work]. ;-)
+'''NOTE''': Check at the part registry the definition of [http://partsregistry.org/RiPS RiPS]
-We reported here the biological function of a new promoter for the part registry that works under starvation periods regulated by cAMP levels, a very useful part for future teams. However, some data is still missing like the mRNA production by this part.  Other teams interested on this part should measure this parameter in order to make a complete characterization of our part.
+===Conclusions===
+The simple pCaiF promoter with crp-cAMP binding site has shown activity under limiting nutrient conditions. Therefore, '''this promoter can be used to enable catabolic shifts''' from glucose to '''new degradation pathways'''.
+From our point of view, this part will be very useful for future teams. Please also check the results obtained for the model developed for this part: [https://2010.igem.org/Team:TU_Delft#page=Modeling/pcaif-model pCaiF regulation model]
+===Future Prospects===
+We would have liked to express our results according to the protocols [http://partsregistry.org/PoPS in the part registry]. Therefore the output of [http://partsregistry.org/Part:BBa_B0032 B0032] and a standard promoter growing on M9 medium has to be measured.
-<html><center><img src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2010/0/00/TU_Delft_project_navigation.jpg" usemap="#projectnavigation" border="0" /></center><map id="projectnavigation" name="projectnavigation"><area shape="rect" alt="Characterization" title="" coords="309,3,591,45" href="https://2010.igem.org/Team:TU_Delft#page=Project/sensing/characterization" target="" /><area shape="rect" alt="Results" title="" coords="609,3,891,44" href="https://2010.igem.org/Team:TU_Delft#page=Project/sensing/results" target="" /><area shape="rect" alt="Parts" title="" coords="9,3,290,44" href="https://2010.igem.org/Team:TU_Delft#page=Project/sensing/parts" target="" /></map></html>
+<html><center><img src="https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2010/0/00/TU_Delft_project_navigation.jpg" usemap="#projectnavigation" border="0" /></center><map id="projectnavigation" name="projectnavigation"><area shape="rect" alt="Characterization" title="" coords="309,3,591,45" href="https://2010.igem.org/Team:TU_Delft#page=Project/solubility/characterization" target="" /><area shape="rect" alt="Results" title="" coords="609,3,891,44" href="https://2010.igem.org/Team:TU_Delft#page=Project/solubility/results" target="" /><area shape="rect" alt="Parts" title="" coords="9,3,290,44" href="https://2010.igem.org/Team:TU_Delft#page=Project/solubility/parts" target="" /></map></html>