Team:Berkeley/Results

From 2010.igem.org

(Difference between revisions)
 
(64 intermediate revisions not shown)
Line 8: Line 8:
-
''''' General Experimental Set Up'''''<br>
+
== General Experimental Set Up==
-
In general to assay payload delivery, we first
+
Our payload delivery assay involves the following steps:
# Feed the payload bacteria to the choanos and induce self-lysis with arabinose. Induction of self lysis and feeding are not necessarily at the same time.  
# Feed the payload bacteria to the choanos and induce self-lysis with arabinose. Induction of self lysis and feeding are not necessarily at the same time.  
-
# Next, we assay for successful delivery events!
+
# Use fluorescent microscopy to detect delivery of our GFP payload.<br>
-
 
+
-
SInce the payload we used in our assays was GFP, we assayed for delivery events using fluorescent microscopy. <br>
+
'''''Challenges'''''
'''''Challenges'''''
-
One of the challenges we faced in assaying for payload delivery was finding a media that the choanos liked and that the payload bacteria were able to lyse in. After assaying several different media formulations, including CMG3, LB, TB, ASW and four different mixtures of ASW and LB, we found was that CMG3 media was the best media for choanos in which we were able to get substantial lysis. <br>
+
One of the challenges we faced in assaying for payload delivery was finding a media that the Choanoflagellates liked and that accomodated lysis. After assaying several different media formulations, including CGM, LB, TB, ASW and four different mixtures of ASW and LB, we found that CGM media was the best media for Choano viability, E. Coli lysis, and protein delivery. For more details, see our characterization of the [https://2010.igem.org/Team:Berkeley/Project/Self_Lysis self-lysis device]. <br>
-
The major challenge we faced with assaying for payload delivery was determining the timing of when to induce self-lysis and when to look at the choanos under the microscope.
+
The major challenge we faced when assaying for payload delivery was determining when to induce self-lysis and when to look at the choanos under the microscope.
-
For induction of self lysis, we tested timepoints from 90 minutes before feeding the choanos to 30 minutes after feeding the choanos, with 15 minute intervals. For looking at the choanos under the microscope, we tested timepoints from 1 hour after feeding to 24 hours after feeding.<br>
+
For induction of self lysis, we tested timepoints from 90 minutes to 30 minutes after feeding the choanos (-90 to +30 minutes), with 15 minute intervals. For looking at the choanos under the microscope, we tested timepoints from 1 hour after feeding to 24 hours after feeding.<br>
[[Image:Screen shot 2010-10-25 at 10.02.59 PM.png|700px]]
[[Image:Screen shot 2010-10-25 at 10.02.59 PM.png|700px]]
-
From our experiments, we found that induction at the same time as feeding, or 15 or 30 minutes after feeding yielded the most delivery events. For timepoints before 15 minute before feeding, the number of delivery events drops off fairly steeply. '''SUPPORT WITH HEMOCYTOMETER DATA'''  <br>
+
From our experiments, we found that induction at the same time as feeding, or 15 or 30 minutes after feeding yielded the most delivery events. For timepoints before -15 minute, delivery events were undetectable or happened extremely infrequently. <br>
We  also observed  that choanos seem to eat and digest bacteria with 1-2 hours after feeding, and that the best time to look for successful delivery was between 3 and 5 hours after feeding. <br>
We  also observed  that choanos seem to eat and digest bacteria with 1-2 hours after feeding, and that the best time to look for successful delivery was between 3 and 5 hours after feeding. <br>
-
''''' Controls and Assay Results'''''
+
===Controls===
-
Our first step before assaying was to establish controls for all of our assay experiments. Based on how our parts should work, and work done in the Anderson Lab in mammalian cells, we expected that a sucessful delivery event would look like a choano who's cytoplasm was completely filled with GFP. With this in mind, the controls we ran regarding the choanos were:
+
Our first step before assaying was to establish controls. Based on how our parts should work, and work done in the Anderson Lab in mammalian cells, we expected that a sucessful delivery event would consist of diffuse GFP fluorescence throughout a choano's cytoplasm. With this in mind, the controls we ran regarding the choanos were:
 +
 
 +
====Payload cells with no payload delivery device====
 +
 
 +
This control was to establish  a baseline of what normal eating and digestion of bacteria in choanos looks like. We observed that choanos seem to eat with 3-5 minutes after feeding. During the first hour or so, one generally sees bacteria in food vesicles , either as rod shapes or circles (rod shaped bacteria 'head on'). They are very bright and have signifcant halos. Slowly, we end up seeing fluorescence in small circular objects.The fluorescent intensity is less than the initial bacteria in food vesicles, and we believe flourescent payload is in the food vacuole.  Eventually, the fluorescence disappears altogther, degraded by the vacuole of the choano.
 +
 
 +
<table>
 +
  <tr>
 +
  <td>
 +
    [[Image:Choano-1hour-plain payload.jpg|thumb|300px|Choanos fed just payload cells with no payload delivery device after 1 hour.  You can see rod shaped bacteria in food vesicles in the choanos. Imaged at 100 ms, green channel exposure]]
 +
  </td>
 +
  <td>
 +
      [[Image:Controldigestionandwhole300nice_(c2+c6).JPG|thumb|300px|Choanos fed just payload cells with no payload delivery device after  3 hours . You can see a couple rod shaped bacteria inside of of choanos as well as many choanos with dimmer fluorescent circles, which we believe is gfp in the food vacuole, imaged at 300ms green channel exposure]]
 +
  </td>
 +
  </tr>
 +
</table>
 +
 
 +
 
 +
 
 +
====Payload cells with uninduced payload delivery device====
 +
This control was to ascertain that any delivery events we got were from induction with arabinose, and not just a normal phenotype exhibited  when choanos eat cells with self-lysis, vesicle buster and payload. 
 +
 
 +
<table>
 +
  <tr>
 +
  <td>
 +
    [[Image:Justpayload_3_(c2+c6).JPG|thumb|300px|Choanos fed just uninduced payload cells with self-lysis device and vesicle buster.  We did not see any successful delivery and this image shows choanos with bacteria in their food vacuoles, in the process of normal digestion. Imaged at 300 ms, green channel exposure]]
 +
  </td>
 +
  </tr>
 +
</table>
 +
 
 +
====Cells with payload and self lysis but ''no'' vesicle buster====
 +
 
 +
This control was to confirm that the successful delivery phenotype we saw was due to self-lysis device '''and''' the vesicle buster, not just self-lysis alone. We wanted to make sure that the what we were seeing was payload that had escaped the food vesicle, not just payload in a food vesicle.
 +
 
 +
<table>
 +
  <tr>
 +
  <td>
 +
    [[Image:1968-4hrs-1_(c2+c6).JPG|thumb|300px|Choanos fed just payload cells with only self-lysis after 3 hours.  You can see fluorescence inside the food vacuoles of choanos.  Imaged at 300 ms, green channel exposure]]
 +
  </td>
 +
  </tr>
 +
</table>
 +
 
 +
====Cells with payload and vesicle buster, but ''no'' self-lysis====
 +
This control was once again to make sure that if we saw a successful delivery event, we could be certain that it was a phenotype unique to cells with induced self-lysis '''and''' vesicle buster.
 +
 
 +
<table>
 +
  <tr>
 +
  <td>
 +
    [[Image:2347_3_(c2+c6).JPG|thumb|300px|Choanos fed  payload cells with only vesicle buster.  You can see bacteria in food vacuole in the choanos. Imaged at 300 ms, green channel exposure]]
 +
  </td>
 +
  </tr>
 +
</table>
-
#'''payload cells with no payload delivery device'''- This control was to establish  a baseline of what normal eating and digestion of bacteria in choanos looks like. We observed that choanos seem to eat with 3-5 minutes after feeding. During the first hour or so, one generally sees bacteria in food vesicles , either as rod shapes or circles (rod shaped bacteria 'head on'). They are very bright and have signifcant halos. Slowly, we end up seeing fluorescence in small circular objects.The fluorescent intensity is less than the initial bacteria in food vesicles, and we believe flourescent payload is in the food vacuole.  Eventually, the fluorescence disappears altogther, degraded by the vacuole of the choano.
+
Additionally, since all of these assays are microscopy based, we kept the settings on our microscopes constant and kept careful notes on exposure and magnification in order to avoid getting misleading results.  
-
[[Image:Choano-1hour-plain payload.jpg|300 px]]                                                                                        [[Image:Controldigestionandwhole300nice_(c2+c6).JPG|325px]] <br>
+
===Payload Delivery===
-
('''Left Image''')Choanos feed just payload cells with no payload delivery device after 1 hour.  You can see rod shaped bacteria in food vesicles in the choanos. (phase overlayed with green fluoresence, phase 50 ms, GFP 100ms)  ('''Right Image''') Choanos fed just payload cells with no payload delivery device after  3 hours . You can see a couple rod shaped bacteria inside of of choanos as well as many choanos with dimmer fluorescent circles, which we believe is gfp in the food vacuole.(phase overlayed with green fluoresence, phase 50 ms, GFP 300 ms.) <br>
+
-
+
-
#'''payload cells with uninduced payload delivery device'''- This control was to ascertain that any delivery events we got were from induction with arabinose, and not just a normal phenotype exhibited in when choanos eat cells with self-lysis, vesicle buster and payload.
+
The following images are of successful payload delivery events. As the images of the control above showed, the phenotype of GFP throughout the cytoplasm shown below is unique to constructs with self-lysis and vesicle buster, and is consistent with what we'd expect to see based on the biology of our parts.
 +
<table>
 +
  <tr>
 +
  <td>
 +
    [[Image:Time511-51_(-30)_5-100_(c2+c6).JPG|thumb|300px|Successful delivery event, imaged at 100ms green channel exposure]]
 +
  </td>
 +
  <td>
 +
      [[Image:Time511-51_(-30)_5-300_(c2+c6).JPG|thumb|300px|Successful delivery event, imaged at 300ms green channel exposure]]
 +
  </td>
 +
  </tr>
 +
<tr>
 +
<td>
 +
====Confocal Imaging====
 +
</td>
 +
<td>
 +
</td>
 +
</tr>
-
#cells with payload and self lysis but '''no''' vesicle buster- This control was run to make sure that the successful delivery phenotype was saw was due to self-lysis device '''and''' the vesicle buster, not just self-lysis alone. We wanted to make sure that the what we were seeing was payload that had escaped the food vesicle, not just payload in a food vesicle.
+
<tr>
 +
<td>
 +
[[Image:Awesome_fov2_2.jpg|thumb|300px|In this image we can see two delivery events. In the upper left corner, the choano is fixed to the surface of the viewing well in a vertical orientation, (flagella upwards) so it appears circular. In the upper right corner, the choano is lying on its side, and you can see the skirt and flagella.|]]
 +
</td>
 +
<td>
 +
  [[Image:Awesome_fov1.jpg|thumb|300px]]
 +
</td>
 +
</tr>
 +
<tr>
 +
  <td>
 +
  [[Image:3D_left-1.gif|thumb|300px|Z-stack imaging with 1.5 micron slices.]] [[Image:3D_right.gif|thumb|300px|Z-stack imaging with 1.5 micron slices.]]
-
#cells with payload and vacuole buster, but '''no''' self-lysis. - This control was once again to make sure that if we saw a successful delivery event, we could be certain that it was a phenotype unique to cells with induced self-lysis '''and'''vacuole buster.
+
  </td>
 +
  <td>
 +
    [[Image:Orthoview.jpg|thumb|300px|Ortho-view of z-stack imaging]]
 +
  </td>
 +
</tr>
-
Additionally, we considered controls related to fluorescent microscope settings. When imaging choanos, we kept in mind that  with fluorescent microscopy, it would be easy to get misleading results if one is not careful to keep track of settings on the microscope, so we made sure to keep the exposure settings on the microscope fairly constant when running each assay.
+
</table>
 +
====Efficiency of GFP Delivery: 7% (±2%)====
 +
We also used a hemocytometer to quantify the frequency of delivery.  For an assay with self-lysis induction 15 minutes after feeding, an average of 7% (±2% standard deviation) of choanoflagellates experienced successful delivery of GFP -  1 out of every 16 choanos. In a culture at average density (10^6 cells per mL), we will have approximately 6.2x10^4 delivery events per mL of culture.
-
'''''Specific Protocols'''''
+
'''''Protocol for Assaying'''''
-
or time points before feeding, we induce self lysis in a testube, and then put it in a 37 degree shaker until it is time to feed the choanos. For time points after feeding, we add arabinose to the choanos and keep them incubating at 37 C until we assay.
+
The following are the steps we follow in order to set up and assay for payload delivery.
 +
# Grow up payload bacteria in TB for approximately 16 hours.
 +
# We generally culture our choanos in sea water, so the first step is to aspirate off the seawater, and replace it with CGM3, a media bacteria are able to lyse in. Since choanos naturally fix to the surface of the dish they are cultured in, this step pretty straightforward.
 +
# Aliquot 2 mLs of payload bacteria into two test tubes and induce one with arabinose. Put them in the 37 C shaker/incubator. This is to test for lysis before assaying using the microscope, because there is no point in assaying if the cells don't even lyse in test tubes.
 +
# Induce lysis in cells. For time points that are before feeding, we induce lysis in a test tube, and put it in the shaker at 37 C until it is time to feed. For time points after feeding, we induce self-lysis and put the choanos in the 37 C incubator, without shaking.
 +
# Feed the choanos. We generally feed 2 uls of bacteria  per 500 ul of choanos.
 +
# Put the choanos that have been fed in the  37 C incubator for 3 hours.
 +
# After 3 hours, remove the choanos, and look at them under the microscope.

Latest revision as of 03:10, 28 October 2010

Experimental results header.png



General Experimental Set Up

Our payload delivery assay involves the following steps:

  1. Feed the payload bacteria to the choanos and induce self-lysis with arabinose. Induction of self lysis and feeding are not necessarily at the same time.
  2. Use fluorescent microscopy to detect delivery of our GFP payload.

Challenges

One of the challenges we faced in assaying for payload delivery was finding a media that the Choanoflagellates liked and that accomodated lysis. After assaying several different media formulations, including CGM, LB, TB, ASW and four different mixtures of ASW and LB, we found that CGM media was the best media for Choano viability, E. Coli lysis, and protein delivery. For more details, see our characterization of the self-lysis device.

The major challenge we faced when assaying for payload delivery was determining when to induce self-lysis and when to look at the choanos under the microscope. For induction of self lysis, we tested timepoints from 90 minutes to 30 minutes after feeding the choanos (-90 to +30 minutes), with 15 minute intervals. For looking at the choanos under the microscope, we tested timepoints from 1 hour after feeding to 24 hours after feeding.

Screen shot 2010-10-25 at 10.02.59 PM.png

From our experiments, we found that induction at the same time as feeding, or 15 or 30 minutes after feeding yielded the most delivery events. For timepoints before -15 minute, delivery events were undetectable or happened extremely infrequently.

We also observed that choanos seem to eat and digest bacteria with 1-2 hours after feeding, and that the best time to look for successful delivery was between 3 and 5 hours after feeding.


Controls

Our first step before assaying was to establish controls. Based on how our parts should work, and work done in the Anderson Lab in mammalian cells, we expected that a sucessful delivery event would consist of diffuse GFP fluorescence throughout a choano's cytoplasm. With this in mind, the controls we ran regarding the choanos were:

Payload cells with no payload delivery device

This control was to establish a baseline of what normal eating and digestion of bacteria in choanos looks like. We observed that choanos seem to eat with 3-5 minutes after feeding. During the first hour or so, one generally sees bacteria in food vesicles , either as rod shapes or circles (rod shaped bacteria 'head on'). They are very bright and have signifcant halos. Slowly, we end up seeing fluorescence in small circular objects.The fluorescent intensity is less than the initial bacteria in food vesicles, and we believe flourescent payload is in the food vacuole. Eventually, the fluorescence disappears altogther, degraded by the vacuole of the choano.

Choanos fed just payload cells with no payload delivery device after 1 hour. You can see rod shaped bacteria in food vesicles in the choanos. Imaged at 100 ms, green channel exposure
Choanos fed just payload cells with no payload delivery device after 3 hours . You can see a couple rod shaped bacteria inside of of choanos as well as many choanos with dimmer fluorescent circles, which we believe is gfp in the food vacuole, imaged at 300ms green channel exposure


Payload cells with uninduced payload delivery device

This control was to ascertain that any delivery events we got were from induction with arabinose, and not just a normal phenotype exhibited when choanos eat cells with self-lysis, vesicle buster and payload.

Choanos fed just uninduced payload cells with self-lysis device and vesicle buster. We did not see any successful delivery and this image shows choanos with bacteria in their food vacuoles, in the process of normal digestion. Imaged at 300 ms, green channel exposure

Cells with payload and self lysis but no vesicle buster

This control was to confirm that the successful delivery phenotype we saw was due to self-lysis device and the vesicle buster, not just self-lysis alone. We wanted to make sure that the what we were seeing was payload that had escaped the food vesicle, not just payload in a food vesicle.

Choanos fed just payload cells with only self-lysis after 3 hours. You can see fluorescence inside the food vacuoles of choanos. Imaged at 300 ms, green channel exposure

Cells with payload and vesicle buster, but no self-lysis

This control was once again to make sure that if we saw a successful delivery event, we could be certain that it was a phenotype unique to cells with induced self-lysis and vesicle buster.

Choanos fed payload cells with only vesicle buster. You can see bacteria in food vacuole in the choanos. Imaged at 300 ms, green channel exposure

Additionally, since all of these assays are microscopy based, we kept the settings on our microscopes constant and kept careful notes on exposure and magnification in order to avoid getting misleading results.

Payload Delivery

The following images are of successful payload delivery events. As the images of the control above showed, the phenotype of GFP throughout the cytoplasm shown below is unique to constructs with self-lysis and vesicle buster, and is consistent with what we'd expect to see based on the biology of our parts.

Successful delivery event, imaged at 100ms green channel exposure
Successful delivery event, imaged at 300ms green channel exposure

Confocal Imaging
Awesome fov2 2.jpg
Awesome fov1.jpg
Z-stack imaging with 1.5 micron slices.
Z-stack imaging with 1.5 micron slices.
Ortho-view of z-stack imaging

Efficiency of GFP Delivery: 7% (±2%)

We also used a hemocytometer to quantify the frequency of delivery. For an assay with self-lysis induction 15 minutes after feeding, an average of 7% (±2% standard deviation) of choanoflagellates experienced successful delivery of GFP - 1 out of every 16 choanos. In a culture at average density (10^6 cells per mL), we will have approximately 6.2x10^4 delivery events per mL of culture.


Protocol for Assaying The following are the steps we follow in order to set up and assay for payload delivery.

  1. Grow up payload bacteria in TB for approximately 16 hours.
  2. We generally culture our choanos in sea water, so the first step is to aspirate off the seawater, and replace it with CGM3, a media bacteria are able to lyse in. Since choanos naturally fix to the surface of the dish they are cultured in, this step pretty straightforward.
  3. Aliquot 2 mLs of payload bacteria into two test tubes and induce one with arabinose. Put them in the 37 C shaker/incubator. This is to test for lysis before assaying using the microscope, because there is no point in assaying if the cells don't even lyse in test tubes.
  4. Induce lysis in cells. For time points that are before feeding, we induce lysis in a test tube, and put it in the shaker at 37 C until it is time to feed. For time points after feeding, we induce self-lysis and put the choanos in the 37 C incubator, without shaking.
  5. Feed the choanos. We generally feed 2 uls of bacteria per 500 ul of choanos.
  6. Put the choanos that have been fed in the 37 C incubator for 3 hours.
  7. After 3 hours, remove the choanos, and look at them under the microscope.
Retrieved from "http://2010.igem.org/Team:Berkeley/Results"